* Paul Gerhardt is not a real doctor,
but a doctoral student and a practicing Master Organizational Leadership
Therapist
Getting
Published
Part
1 This begins a series of articles devoted to the question that is arguably
the one most often asked by learners: How do I get published? This is
one of those questions that will get a wide variety of answers, however,
depending on the experiences of the person answering the question. Still,
there are a few generalizations that apply.
Generalization Number 1:
It is much, much better to publish in a refereed journal than in one
that is not. While it might be somewhat gratifying to have a letter
to the editor or an article published in USA Today, and it does have
the effect of adding to your list of publications, it will not be viewed
as credible in the world of academe.
Generalization Number 2:
Do some research. You will need to submit your work to a journal that
publishes in your field, and more specifically in your subject area.
This will require a bit of research on your part. There are a host of
journals that publish articles on just about any subject you might think
of. You should develop a list of potential candidates before actually
submitting anything. This leads to prioritizing the list when you are
ready to submit.
Generalization Number 3:
While it is important to format manuscript submissions in the manner
prescribed by the journal (see "Instructions to Authors" provided in
each issue), you should not second-guess the editors by trying to revise
the content of your work in a manner you think might be acceptable to
the editorial review committee. Submit it as you wrote it. The editors
will help you modify it after the decision to publish.
Generalization Number 4:
Be patient. It can take months before you will receive an answer. Many
journals operate from "themes" for each issue. Your submission may not
relate to a theme the editors have scheduled for some time. And even
if it does relate, it can be up to a year between acceptance and actual
publication.
Generalization Number 5:
Don't start with the most prestigious journal in the field. The odds
that a Business School learner will get published by Harvard Business
Review on his or her first attempt at publication are exceedingly small
and verge on the near impossible. Select responsible but credible journals,
and not the more prestigious ones for your initial submissions. After
your reputation for quality work is established, consider the more prestigious
ones.
Generalization Number 6:
Some journals will restrict you from submitting to others while they
are considering your work. Others will not. Be sure you know each journal's
rules before considering multiple simultaneous submissions.
Generalization Number 7:
Don't be sensitive or easily disappointed by rejection. Publication
decisions are often made on criteria that have nothing to do with the
quality of your work. You should expect to receive many more rejections
than you will acceptances. It is the rare occurrence that someone is
published on the first try. And even then, it may seem like forever
before the second one is published.
Getting Published - Part 2 This is the second and last
article devoted to the question that is arguably the one most often asked
by learners: How do I get published? This article discusses conversion
of course papers, etc., to articles.
The most important thing to remember in converting a course paper (or
other academic work product) into an article is that you write for a different
audience. The general approach to writing an academic paper is to assume
that your audience is "educated, but not knowledgeable." As such, you
provide definitions and explanations that may go beyond what would be
necessary in an article.
If you wrote a course paper that discussed the cost effectiveness of an
Employee Assistance Program (EAP), for example, you would normally devote
some of the paper to informing the reader what an EAP was, what its objectives
were, and how it operated. Depending on the journal you targeted for submission,
such background information might not be necessary, especially if the
journal was one that specialized in the EAP field.
Another area you pay attention to in writing course papers is professional
jargon. While there are conventions to handle jargon within a course paper
(define it to the reader!), jargon may be perfectly acceptable without
special handling in an article. A review of other articles in the journal
will give you an idea of how other authors deal with it.
Journal articles are typically more direct and to-the-point than academic
papers. At Capella, however, we prefer that learners write in a more direct
manner, using active voice, and short, 20-25 word sentences, etc. If you
are successful in writing this way, there will probably be little or no
text revision at this point. Stand by for the journal's editors, however;
they always seem to have a mind of their own!
You should not try and second-guess the editorial review board of the
journal by trying to revise the work (see Generalization #3 in the previous
article). It would not be unreasonable, however, for you to read a few
of the articles printed in the journal to get a feel for the style and
tone that are expressed by the authors. Applying that style and tone to
your own submission may reduce editing later in the process.
Next, some more words about rejections. Use them to your advantage. If
your submission is rejected, don't be reluctant to write back and ask
for a recommendation on another journal that might be interested in your
manuscript (you might even get this before you ask). Some journals will
provide a short critique in their rejection. Heed their advice, they provide
it from experience. And if they don't provide it, ask for it. Every little
bit helps.
Getting published is not easy. There are many more submissions than there
are published articles. Don't be discouraged, persistence (mixed with
a little serendipity) is often the key.
In general, the same approach to publication applies to those of you that
might seek to publish your dissertations as a book. Because there are
much fewer books published than articles, the challenge is even more imposing,
and the risks of your efforts being rejected are much higher. Still, here
are a few tips:
There are a number of books and monographs that provide
help in converting dissertations to books. They are not particularly
expensive ($5-$15) and might be worth purchasing and reading before
you decide to seek publication. And if you do decide to publish, they
will help you revise your manuscript and prepare the dissertation for
submission.
Do some research to determine which publishers print
books in your subject area. Narrow your list of prospects to those most
likely to be interested in your work.
Solicit publisher interest BEFORE you undertake to
revise the dissertation. Usually, you can do this by sending the publisher
a 3-5 page summary of the work, together with a cover letter expressing
your interest.
Good luck!
My
mission
is to help organizations develop high performance teams enriched with
trust, respect and support. Contact
Paul@LeadershipSuccessnet